Upvote Upvoted 7 Downvote Downvoted
Would you kill Dumbledore if he asked you to?
posted in Off Topic
1
#1
0 Frags +

No trolls please. Serious discussions only on this very serious matter.

No trolls please. Serious discussions only on this very serious matter.
2
#2
35 Frags +

Yes. Albus is the wisest man I've ever known...if the deed must be done then so be it.

Yes. Albus is the wisest man I've ever known...if the deed must be done then so be it.
3
#3
-5 Frags +

No, I value my soul too much. I like it in one piece.

No, I value my soul too much. I like it in one piece.
4
#4
8 Frags +

I would kill that old guy with one swift blow to the head, LOL

I would kill that old guy with one swift blow to the head, LOL
5
#5
3 Frags +
BilbertNo, I value my soul too much. I like it in one piece.

No horcrux jokes ! This is a serious matter !

[quote=Bilbert]No, I value my soul too much. I like it in one piece.[/quote]

No horcrux jokes ! This is a serious matter !
6
#6
-3 Frags +

Lads a piece of shit fuck him

Lads a piece of shit fuck him
7
#7
5 Frags +

Dumbledore doesn't exist *tips wizard hat*

Dumbledore doesn't exist *tips wizard hat*
8
#8
12 Frags +

he can damn well do it himself

he can damn well do it himself
9
#9
2 Frags +

lmao what do you need me for old man just use a gun or a noose ahahaha grow up

lmao what do you need me for old man just use a gun or a noose ahahaha grow up
10
#10
-7 Frags +

wtF who is him o_o

wtF who is him o_o
11
#11
-2 Frags +

I'd kill him even if he didn't ask. Abusive ass piece of shit. Leave Harry with the fucking Dursleys despite knowing full well that they're the worst people alive? Literally raise him just to fucking die at the right moment? Jesus fuck I'd fucking strangle him if he appeared in front of me right now no questions asked

I'd kill him even if he didn't ask. Abusive ass piece of shit. Leave Harry with the fucking Dursleys despite knowing full well that they're the worst people alive? Literally raise him just to fucking die at the right moment? Jesus fuck I'd fucking strangle him if he appeared in front of me right now no questions asked
12
#12
11 Frags +
Azazel-I'd kill him even if he didn't ask. Abusive ass piece of shit. Leave Harry with the fucking Dursleys despite knowing full well that they're the worst people alive? Literally raise him just to fucking die at the right moment? Jesus fuck I'd fucking strangle him if he appeared in front of me right now no questions asked

Fuck you. Dumbledore's Army™ have access to your address. Choose your next words wisely.

[quote=Azazel-]I'd kill him even if he didn't ask. Abusive ass piece of shit. Leave Harry with the fucking Dursleys despite knowing full well that they're the worst people alive? Literally raise him just to fucking die at the right moment? Jesus fuck I'd fucking strangle him if he appeared in front of me right now no questions asked[/quote]

Fuck you. Dumbledore's Army™ have access to your address. Choose your next words wisely.
13
#13
18 Frags +

No aha Dumbledore I can't do it ur so sexy aha

No aha Dumbledore I can't do it ur so sexy aha
14
#14
1 Frags +
Azazel-I'd kill him even if he didn't ask. Abusive ass piece of shit. Leave Harry with the fucking Dursleys despite knowing full well that they're the worst people alive? Literally raise him just to fucking die at the right moment? Jesus fuck I'd fucking strangle him if he appeared in front of me right now no questions asked

Read the books.

[quote=Azazel-]I'd kill him even if he didn't ask. Abusive ass piece of shit. Leave Harry with the fucking Dursleys despite knowing full well that they're the worst people alive? Literally raise him just to fucking die at the right moment? Jesus fuck I'd fucking strangle him if he appeared in front of me right now no questions asked[/quote]
Read the books.
15
#15
3 Frags +

I'm not letting dumbledore get off that easily. He has to face The Allegations.

I'm not letting dumbledore get off that easily. He has to face The Allegations.
16
#16
0 Frags +
Spannshe can damn well do it himself

but then how will you fully gain the trust of voldemort?

[quote=Spanns]he can damn well do it himself[/quote]
but then how will you fully gain the trust of voldemort?
17
#17
-1 Frags +
LupusBilbertNo, I value my soul too much. I like it in one piece.
No horcrux jokes ! This is a serious matter !

What are you talking about? The act of killing another human splits the soul apart. A horcrux is when you put that fragment of your soul into an object.

[quote=Lupus][quote=Bilbert]No, I value my soul too much. I like it in one piece.[/quote]

No horcrux jokes ! This is a serious matter ![/quote]
What are you talking about? The act of killing another human splits the soul apart. A horcrux is when you put that fragment of your soul into an object.
18
#18
-2 Frags +

me: lists a series of activities that Dumbledore does in the books as proof that he's a piece of shit.
you: read the books

wow, you got me there

me: lists a series of activities that Dumbledore does in the books as proof that he's a piece of shit.
you: read the books

wow, you got me there
19
#19
0 Frags +

ngl id trade harry for the rest of the world easily too emo cunt

ngl id trade harry for the rest of the world easily too emo cunt
20
#20
ESEA
22 Frags +

If you kill someone at their request to put them out of their misery when they know they're dying of an incurable illness, it won't split your soul because it's not an evil act

source: On page 548 of ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows’ (Bloomsbury first edition), Dumbledore discusses his motives for his request to Snape.

Snape asks:

Snape“What about my soul?”

Dumbledore replies:

Dumbledore“You alone know whether it will harm your soul to help an old man avoid pain and humiliation.”
If you kill someone at their request to put them out of their misery when they know they're dying of an incurable illness, it won't split your soul because it's not an evil act

source: On page 548 of ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows’ (Bloomsbury first edition), Dumbledore discusses his motives for his request to Snape.

Snape asks: [quote=Snape]“What about my soul?”[/quote]

Dumbledore replies:

[quote=Dumbledore]“You alone know whether it will harm your soul to help an old man avoid pain and humiliation.”[/quote]
21
#21
-6 Frags +

ok boomer

ok boomer
22
#22
7 Frags +
tri_If you kill someone at their request to put them out of their misery when they know they're dying of an incurable illness, it won't split your soul because it's not an evil act

source:

https://archive-media-0.nyafuu.org/vp/image/1551/30/1551300060713.png

[quote=tri_]If you kill someone at their request to put them out of their misery when they know they're dying of an incurable illness, it won't split your soul because it's not an evil act

source:[/quote]
[img]https://archive-media-0.nyafuu.org/vp/image/1551/30/1551300060713.png[/img]
23
#23
2 Frags +

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9tV9G1oaUM

[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9tV9G1oaUM[/youtube]
24
#24
1 Frags +

harry potter is my brother

harry potter is my brother
25
#25
-4 Frags +
griffhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9tV9G1oaUM

this is my son

[quote=griff][youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9tV9G1oaUM[/youtube][/quote]
this is my son
26
#26
1 Frags +

Are we basically putting ourselves in Snape's shoes or is this a more general, "Would you kill him if he asked" question?

Are we basically putting ourselves in Snape's shoes or is this a more general, "Would you kill him if he asked" question?
27
#27
5 Frags +

dragonwarrior12 killed dumbledore

dragonwarrior12 killed dumbledore
28
#28
7 Frags +
tri_If you kill someone at their request to put them out of their misery when they know they're dying of an incurable illness, it won't split your soul because it's not an evil act

source:

https://production-gameflipusercontent.fingershock.com/us-east-1:9d262ada-0cd0-487b-ab8d-6166b702ad5e/426abfbf-9dd1-4dd8-8608-8c923540fd8c/ffe7a334-bf82-466d-afe4-284ff0602435

[quote=tri_]If you kill someone at their request to put them out of their misery when they know they're dying of an incurable illness, it won't split your soul because it's not an evil act

source:[/quote]

[img]https://production-gameflipusercontent.fingershock.com/us-east-1:9d262ada-0cd0-487b-ab8d-6166b702ad5e/426abfbf-9dd1-4dd8-8608-8c923540fd8c/ffe7a334-bf82-466d-afe4-284ff0602435[/img]
29
#29
0 Frags +

dumbledore why dont u have a seat ? :)

dumbledore why dont u have a seat ? :)
Please sign in through STEAM to post a comment.