Upvote Upvoted 2 Downvote Downvoted
mechanical keyboard switches
posted in Hardware
1
#1
1 Frags +

I plan on replacing my Steelseries 6gv2 (black switches) with a Noppoo Choc Mini this week and dont really know which switches to go with. Red, brown, blue, or stay with black? Im kinda considering the browns based off this: http://www.daskeyboard.com/blog/?page_id=1458#keyswitches
What are your thoughts/opinions/recommendations?

Also, I want to teach myself how to type proper instead of using just two fingers pecking at keys. Would a simple site like the be fine enough? http://www.typingweb.com/

Edit: Forgot to put this in 'Hardware' :|

I plan on replacing my Steelseries 6gv2 (black switches) with a Noppoo Choc Mini this week and dont really know which switches to go with. Red, brown, blue, or stay with black? Im kinda considering the browns based off this: http://www.daskeyboard.com/blog/?page_id=1458#keyswitches
What are your thoughts/opinions/recommendations?

Also, I want to teach myself how to type proper instead of using just two fingers pecking at keys. Would a simple site like the be fine enough? http://www.typingweb.com/

Edit: Forgot to put this in 'Hardware' :|
2
#2
3 Frags +

I'm tired of these keyboard threads every 3-4 days. Do we need a stickied topic just for keyboards?

I'm tired of these keyboard threads every 3-4 days. Do we need a stickied topic just for keyboards?
3
#3
1 Frags +

Although this is a very 'personal preference' type decision, I would go with red or brown. Red and brown are both very light keys (they have the same springs iirc). Personally, my fingers get tired using blacks. Reds are the same thing as blacks except they require less force for actuation. Browns are effectively reds, except there is a very light click upon actuation. Personally I much prefer the light feedback of browns to the much more noticeable (both feel and sound) feedback of blues. Personally, I prefer browns for typing and reds for gaming, although the difference is very negligible for me.

Although this is a very 'personal preference' type decision, I would go with red or brown. Red and brown are both very light keys (they have the same springs iirc). Personally, my fingers get tired using blacks. Reds are the same thing as blacks except they require less force for actuation. Browns are effectively reds, except there is a very light click upon actuation. Personally I much prefer the light feedback of browns to the much more noticeable (both feel and sound) feedback of blues. Personally, I prefer browns for typing and reds for gaming, although the difference is very negligible for me.
4
#4
1 Frags +

I have a keyboard I've used for 2 years with Cherry MX Browns. I've played on blues and now reds. The only ones I havent played on are blacks and greens. Browns are ok but a bit noisy. Blue's are even louder because they have a built in clicking mechanism to show you've gone far enough to trigger. Red's are linear with no bump (similar to black's but without the force needed). I have sound dampeners on my Reds and I highly recommend them. As frkn said red or brown. Blue is too loud, black too much force.

I have a keyboard I've used for 2 years with Cherry MX Browns. I've played on blues and now reds. The only ones I havent played on are blacks and greens. Browns are ok but a bit noisy. Blue's are even louder because they have a built in clicking mechanism to show you've gone far enough to trigger. Red's are linear with no bump (similar to black's but without the force needed). I have sound dampeners on my Reds and I highly recommend them. As frkn said red or brown. Blue is too loud, black too much force.
5
#5
1 Frags +
brownymasterI'm tired of these keyboard threads every 3-4 days. Do we need a stickied topic just for keyboards?

Probably would be useful. I searched but couldnt find one.

[quote=brownymaster]I'm tired of these keyboard threads every 3-4 days. Do we need a stickied topic just for keyboards?[/quote]
Probably would be useful. I searched but couldnt find one.
6
#6
-1 Frags +
disengagebrownymasterI'm tired of these keyboard threads every 3-4 days. Do we need a stickied topic just for keyboards?Probably would be useful. I searched but couldnt find one.

http://teamfortress.tv/forum/category/11
Just go to any keyboard thread:
http://teamfortress.tv/forum/thread/3568-keyboard
http://teamfortress.tv/forum/thread/3334-entry-level-mechanical-keyboard-w-mx-blues
http://teamfortress.tv/forum/thread/2784-need-help-with-a-keyboard

And last of all, the first page you get when googling a mechanical keyboard switches is the overclock thread. You should always google for something hardware related first, because that is literally the holy grail of all mechanical keyboard guides and can't be missed if you google it.
http://www.overclock.net/t/491752/mechanical-keyboard-guide

[quote=disengage][quote=brownymaster]I'm tired of these keyboard threads every 3-4 days. Do we need a stickied topic just for keyboards?[/quote]
Probably would be useful. I searched but couldnt find one.[/quote]
http://teamfortress.tv/forum/category/11
Just go to any keyboard thread:
http://teamfortress.tv/forum/thread/3568-keyboard
http://teamfortress.tv/forum/thread/3334-entry-level-mechanical-keyboard-w-mx-blues
http://teamfortress.tv/forum/thread/2784-need-help-with-a-keyboard

And last of all, the first page you get when googling a mechanical keyboard switches is the overclock thread. You should always google for something hardware related first, because that is literally the holy grail of all mechanical keyboard guides and can't be missed if you google it.
http://www.overclock.net/t/491752/mechanical-keyboard-guide
7
#7
1 Frags +

Thanks browny. It was late last night I didnt feel like doing a bunch of research so I made this thread real quick to get some responses when I woke up. I plan on doing a lot of my own research today

Thanks browny. It was late last night I didnt feel like doing a bunch of research so I made this thread real quick to get some responses when I woke up. I plan on doing a lot of my own research today
8
#8
3 Frags +

hmm maybe i'll make an article for a sticky thread

hmm maybe i'll make an article for a sticky thread
9
#9
0 Frags +

I have a keyboard with Browns which is supposed to get here tomorrow. After a lot of research i decided to go for browns because they have a lighter actuation force and what everyone describes as the "bump" similar to the blues without the high-pitched click that i was worried would annoy my roommate. Lots of people say the blues are not ideal because the reset point is higher than the actuation point which is weird for gaming. On the other hand if you are doing a lot of typing the blues seem to be the accepted standard for favorite typing switch. Honestly it seems to be personal preference though, and if you like your blacks i would wager that you would love reds as well.

I have a keyboard with Browns which is supposed to get here tomorrow. After a lot of research i decided to go for browns because they have a lighter actuation force and what everyone describes as the "bump" similar to the blues without the high-pitched click that i was worried would annoy my roommate. Lots of people say the blues are not ideal because the reset point is higher than the actuation point which is weird for gaming. On the other hand if you are doing a lot of typing the blues seem to be the accepted standard for favorite typing switch. Honestly it seems to be personal preference though, and if you like your blacks i would wager that you would love reds as well.
10
#10
-2 Frags +

The lack of feedback with reds will fuck you up if you use a crouch jump script.

The lack of feedback with reds will fuck you up if you use a crouch jump script.
11
#11
0 Frags +
ndustThe lack of feedback with reds will fuck you up if you use a crouch jump script.

umm, what?

It doesn't mess me up at all...

[quote=ndust]The lack of feedback with reds will fuck you up if you use a crouch jump script.[/quote]

umm, what?

It doesn't mess me up at all...
12
#12
0 Frags +
milehighmilitiaI have a keyboard with Browns which is supposed to get here tomorrow. After a lot of research i decided to go for browns because they have a lighter actuation force and what everyone describes as the "bump" similar to the blues without the high-pitched click that i was worried would annoy my roommate. Lots of people say the blues are not ideal because the reset point is higher than the actuation point which is weird for gaming. On the other hand if you are doing a lot of typing the blues seem to be the accepted standard for favorite typing switch. Honestly it seems to be personal preference though, and if you like your blacks i would wager that you would love reds as well.

???

The reset point has to be higher than the actuation point. Otherwise, you'd have to push the key down to make it stop sending keystrokes....

Blues are just fine for gaming; they're just extra loud.

ndustThe lack of feedback with reds will fuck you up if you use a crouch jump script.

I don't understand your logic. How could that possibly be linked?

[quote=milehighmilitia]I have a keyboard with Browns which is supposed to get here tomorrow. After a lot of research i decided to go for browns because they have a lighter actuation force and what everyone describes as the "bump" similar to the blues without the high-pitched click that i was worried would annoy my roommate. Lots of people say the blues are not ideal because the reset point is higher than the actuation point which is weird for gaming. On the other hand if you are doing a lot of typing the blues seem to be the accepted standard for favorite typing switch. Honestly it seems to be personal preference though, and if you like your blacks i would wager that you would love reds as well.[/quote]
???

The reset point has to be higher than the actuation point. Otherwise, you'd have to push the key down to make it stop sending keystrokes....

Blues are just fine for gaming; they're just extra loud.


[quote=ndust]The lack of feedback with reds will fuck you up if you use a crouch jump script.[/quote]
I don't understand your logic. How could that possibly be linked?
13
#13
1 Frags +

I just got a Filco with browns today. I love it so far.

It's amazing to type on and feels great for TF2 as well.

I just got a Filco with browns today. I love it so far.

It's amazing to type on and feels great for TF2 as well.
14
#14
1 Frags +

I've used blue switches for about 2 years. They're decent for gaming, but they are loud as shit, and also take a while to get used to. Writing essays and papers on blues feels too amazing to give up though.

I've used blue switches for about 2 years. They're decent for gaming, but they are loud as shit, and also take a while to get used to. Writing essays and papers on blues feels too amazing to give up though.
15
#15
2 Frags +
zigzterI just got a Filco with browns today. I love it so far.

It's amazing to type on and feels great for TF2 as well.

i got the filco majestouch 2 a while ago its so good

[quote=zigzter]I just got a Filco with browns today. I love it so far.

It's amazing to type on and feels great for TF2 as well.[/quote]

i got the filco majestouch 2 a while ago its so good
16
#16
0 Frags +
smakersmilehighmilitiaI have a keyboard with Browns which is supposed to get here tomorrow. After a lot of research i decided to go for browns because they have a lighter actuation force and what everyone describes as the "bump" similar to the blues without the high-pitched click that i was worried would annoy my roommate. Lots of people say the blues are not ideal because the reset point is higher than the actuation point which is weird for gaming. On the other hand if you are doing a lot of typing the blues seem to be the accepted standard for favorite typing switch. Honestly it seems to be personal preference though, and if you like your blacks i would wager that you would love reds as well.???

The reset point has to be higher than the actuation point. Otherwise, you'd have to push the key down to make it stop sending keystrokes....

Blues are just fine for gaming; they're just extra loud.

Blues may indeed be fine for gaming, and I am sure that many people here use them for this, including members of my team, however that does not mean that what I said was incorrect. If you look at the force diagrams for each switch, you will see that the blues are the only switch that do not reset at more or less the same point that they actuate. This essentially means that with blues you have to let the key come up higher before you will be able to register a new keystroke, whereas with the other keys they "turn off" at the same point that they "turn on" so they can theoretically be toggled easier.

http://cdn.overclock.net/8/88/8846736e_785448034edc7cebb9ea660c5f11e288.jpeg

vs.

http://cdn.overclock.net/f/f6/f63f362e_cde2fb0a2dd06fefcc47ce1ed987f6a8.jpeg

Just compare the "Operating Point" to the "Reset Point" to know what i was referencing.

[quote=smakers][quote=milehighmilitia]I have a keyboard with Browns which is supposed to get here tomorrow. After a lot of research i decided to go for browns because they have a lighter actuation force and what everyone describes as the "bump" similar to the blues without the high-pitched click that i was worried would annoy my roommate. Lots of people say the blues are not ideal because the reset point is higher than the actuation point which is weird for gaming. On the other hand if you are doing a lot of typing the blues seem to be the accepted standard for favorite typing switch. Honestly it seems to be personal preference though, and if you like your blacks i would wager that you would love reds as well.[/quote]
???

The reset point has to be higher than the actuation point. Otherwise, you'd have to push the key down to make it stop sending keystrokes....

Blues are just fine for gaming; they're just extra loud.
[/quote]

Blues may indeed be fine for gaming, and I am sure that many people here use them for this, including members of my team, however that does not mean that what I said was incorrect. If you look at the force diagrams for each switch, you will see that the blues are the only switch that do not reset at more or less the same point that they actuate. This essentially means that with blues you have to let the key come up higher before you will be able to register a new keystroke, whereas with the other keys they "turn off" at the same point that they "turn on" so they can theoretically be toggled easier.
[img]http://cdn.overclock.net/8/88/8846736e_785448034edc7cebb9ea660c5f11e288.jpeg[/img]
vs.
[img]http://cdn.overclock.net/f/f6/f63f362e_cde2fb0a2dd06fefcc47ce1ed987f6a8.jpeg[/img]

Just compare the "Operating Point" to the "Reset Point" to know what i was referencing.
17
#17
0 Frags +

Recently got an FC700R. I now swear by browns after using a 7G for a year.

Recently got an FC700R. I now swear by browns after using a 7G for a year.
18
#18
0 Frags +

Rename to mechanical keyboard general cause I have a different question:

Is there a way to mount one of these on top of a regular laptop keyboard, or is there a product like that? My keyboard is pretty high up (from 1.5 to 3.5") because of the cooler.

Rename to mechanical keyboard general cause I have a different question:

Is there a way to mount one of these on top of a regular laptop keyboard, or is there a product like that? My keyboard is pretty high up (from 1.5 to 3.5") because of the cooler.
Please sign in through STEAM to post a comment.