Platinum...
Revise the rules if they can't be applied on literally the first case asked to enforce them?
Revise the rules when they prove to be inadequate? Yes.
Enforce the rules when they prove to be inadequate? No.
At first you suggested to enforce a rule at all times, now you're suggesting to revise it as soon as a problem with it arises? If you're not applying the revised rule in the incident that caused the revision, you're screwing someone over and if you do, you basically didn't enforce the (old) rule.
I might have missed the magical solution hidden beneath your list of problems
(reminder:
PlatinumSo what would you have done if a couple players were getting potentially temporarily ddosed? What if someone happened to lag? What if it wasn't as cut and dry as 3 people crashing outright? What if the team was losing and wanted a round overturned and decided to pull their modems? How would you know??
), but please tell us what rule covers all of these and everything else that could possibly happen so UGC can use that rule and enforce it no matter what might happen.