I used to play at local tourneys every weekend for around 6 years when I was younger; I quit around the time they began really pushing Synchros and it was fairly obvious Konami planned to keep rehashing old ideas as new in order to sell more cards.
Having played mostly pre-Synchro I wouldn't agree with that sentiment that games were decided in 1-3 turns, on average games lasted around the same or longer than most mtg duels, but Yugioh always got a lot of hate (much more so in recent years understandably) for being the "inferior" tcg which always made me a little sad, since it's what I had gotten into and really enjoyed as a kid.