gr8stalinckapWhile yes, the input from players with more experience is going to be generally more valuable and meaningful, that doesn't mean we should automatically throw out ideas from players with less experience.
Let's say we're building a hospital. We've got a whole bunch of architects and contractors and whoever else specializes in building things getting together and putting their years of experience together to make this hospital. A highschooler who wants to be an architect when he grows up shows up and tries to contribute his take on why the team should totally throw away their plans for the hospital and build it using HIS plans that he sketched up in his free time.
Explain why you think this group of professionals should throw away all of their time and experience to listen to the ill-informed, inexperienced, and far-fetched plans of a highschool student. If you can't, you've found out why conductor is correct.
You are trying to build a hospital. The plans are made public. 5000 people sign a petition to make the rooms larger. You don't. Patients become claustrophobic and want to be move out of your hospital because the rooms are too small.
Explain why you didn't think for a second about what the people who are actually going to fill up your hospital have to say about it. if you can't, you've found out why silly generalizations and unprecise metaphors can make almost any opinion sound valid or stupid.