frag movies are like scrapbooks. you get to immortalize moments in time forever in a cool video. you don't even have to make it cinematic for the people to love it cause the gameplay is already pretty. i got into this game cause of big community frag and jump movies, everyone involved putting in effort to be remembered. i knew i was never gonna try and get good enough at the game to make a name as a player so i turned to editing because i still wanted to contribute. for me it started with the idea of just showcasing the clips, then it became about elevating the clips, and then it become about discovering and fleshing out my own creative identity (visually antagonizing tf2rjweekly viewers).
there's so much effort that goes into making the scene happen and as an editor i always felt obligated to at least match the ambition that the players, producers, organizers, etc were putting forth. i wish there were more editors that attempted to innovate or approach frag movie making with the same sort of discipline that players or even sfm animators do.
but also editing this game is ass. how do you frame a shot of a soldier doing a convoluted jump into a bomb into an airshot? most people are gonna just hit you with a real wide fov smooth that captures it all from one perspective. if you wanna make that shot pretty youre gonna have to do some complex camera choreography. the way this game moves has made it so that the vast majority of editors don't even attempt close up shots. a lot of demos are broken, its so difficult to work with non stv demos. i push as much work into sfm as i can to give me more control over everything but then i need to make maps work in sfm by preparing it in hammer. those softwares are evil.
production value is not the grand arbiter of what makes a frag movie special, lightly edited clip dumps will never lose their charm for as long as people care about the game. but i do think a well edited frag movie makes it feel more like an event, the effort and passion went past the gameplay. shoutout uil that guy is the undisputed tf2 frag movie goat.