ETF2L admin credibility has been brought into question by this official http://etf2l.org/matches/74575/. Logs: http://logs.tf/2240852 http://logs.tf/2240874
From the information I have been given, the key points are:
1. The issue arises from Swi (premiership scout for team Mongi Mode / TorritSukinToes that unfortunately folded) playing scout in a division 2 official match for team Surstromming.
2. All mercs for medic being denied (literally all of them) by team Lithuanian Rhapsody. So team Surstomming had to play with their main scout on medic, and a sub scout on scout. (Subs on a team cannot be denied to play in a game, however they are also not denied entry to a roster of a lower division.) They swapped back (so main scout on scout, and sub on medic) second map, so that map is not in question.
3. Scheduling problems resulting in team Lithuanian Rhapsody requesting a reschedule to the next day after accepting a date already. They requested the date be moved to Thursday ON Wednesday after Sunday already being the accepted date. Team Surstromming denied this reschedule.
4. This being a playoffs deciding match.
5. Admins giving advice that affected a team negatively. One admin said that rather than replay the first map, Surstromming is told to play with Swi on medic. Even though Sustromming followed through with this, they still got a default loss for the map. If they had not heeded the advice of an admin, and rather forced a replay of the map then they would POTENTIALLY not be in the same position.
6.The golden cap, team Sustromming played with correct classes and won, so this raises the validity of the main concern of team Lithuanian Rhapsody, which is whether or not having a prem player in the game actually affected the outcome. In other words, the entire map of granary was not played with incorrect classes, so whether or not this should be a complete 3-0 point loss is very questionable.
So what is wrong with how this case was handled, and how can it be done better in the future? Firstly, the admin who handled it should be the only one who handles this case. Whether that was how it was handled, I am not aware. But this should be key. It prevents bias during the decision making process.
Secondly, both teams were aware of the potential of a problem with Swi on scout BEFORE the game began. However, neither team contacted an admin to ask about it. One team used it as leverage to get a default win, whereas the other used it to have a more experienced player on their team play the match. Both are just as bad in my opinion and should have no effect on the outcome. Obviously though, this was given some value for the team that reported the issue, when it shouldn't have been. Any admin that looked at chat logs or inquired about the issue would be able to see it.
Thirdly, the fact it is a playoffs deciding match should have no effect on how it is handled, but based on the words of admins, it was indeed taken into account. Every match is a playoffs deciding match, and should be treated with equal respect.
Fourthly, all mercs being denied resulted in Surstromming being forced to get their only available sub to be able to play the game. Whilst a team is justified in denying every merc, if the admins wish to remain consistent with the match being a playoffs deciding match, then they should have interjected when this arose. At the same time, Surstromming should have raised their problems to the admins, as should Lithuanian Rhapsody raised their concerns about scheduling problems. Both teams are at fault here (imo Lithuanian Rhapsody more so since denying all mercs forces a sub to play, whereas refusing to change the schedule a day before it would be booked us acceptable), but it looks like neither side is really accounted for, which is unfair in this situation.
Fifthly, team Sustromming did not play with incorrect classes for the entire map of granary, raising concerns as to whether or not team Lithuanian Rhapsody would have won the map even if everyone was playing correct classes.
Finally, what I believe is the main problem is that one admin gave advice to a team. This was then ignored and in fact, even though the team was advised by an admin to do something, it didn't have any affect on the results. The enemy team could still ask for a default win. This raises the main concern of inconsistency and whether or not ETF2L is a credible league.
I believe that the correct way to handle this as admins is to not give a default win. The admins should have forced team Lithuanian Rhapsody and team Sustromming to replay their granary week 7 official asap rather than give a default win. WITH Swi on medic. This ensures that the better team on the day will win the map. It remains consistent with all ideals stated by ETF2L admins, as well as being much more reasonable towards both teams.
Since I have few sources for this information, if any of the following 12 people wish to press their side (the 12 players in the official), their information is likely much more fair and reasonable than mine since they are first person viewers of this debacle. Team Surstromming: Daemon, _gar, Racso, Swi, z0diack, hamaham. Team Lithuanian Rhapsody: Foz, Five baz, Shpeeisme, NeuTronas, Detoed., tuja