in all seriousness, tf2 is such an amateur, diy scene that I don't think people are 100% used to the idea of the true traditional 2-person casting model, ie play-by-play and color
if people are criticizing you for not doing analysis, or for asking seemingly dumb/obvious questions of marxist or whoever just to setup their analysis, then they don't understand how casting is actually supposed to work
if they think you try too much to actually do analysis yourself, and it isn't accurate, then that's a fair criticism. if they think you miss too many important kills/plays, then that's a fair criticism.
honestly, it's pretty hard to tell what the main criticisms of you are, not having watched much of your casting, cuz this community is filled with 14 year olds and they just bandwagon without putting thought into things