Kave_JohnsonCow Mangler 5000 (it's a mess)
Please elaborate. I fail to see how unlimited ammo in exchange for the inability to push down Engineer buildings is a "mess."
Kave_JohnsonMantreads (What's the purpose?)
Is that a legitimate question? Because it's clearly a for-fun item. If you're looking to see it used in competitive play, stop thinking so hard.
Kave_JohnsonDisciplinary Action (when entire games revolve around the use of one weapon and its not a Medic one, you know there is an issue)
How about the Sticky Launcher? Comp seems to revolve around that quite heavily.
Kave_JohnsonHomewrecker (sapper removal is dumb)
Why is it dumb? Are you retarded?
Kave_JohnsonUllapool Caber (the hell was Valve thinking?)
It's another for-fun item. I don't see an imbalance either. If a Demoman is close enough to Caber you, you're probably not very good anyway.