tf2 has lots of players banned slurs, harassment, and generally being a nuisance.
this is a good thing for many reasons: it keeps a more professional appearance for outside eyes, it prevents vulnerable players from being harassed, it deters sportsmanship from devolving into a toxic cesspool.
However, it is also a bad thing: fewer players play in the already thin divisions, punishment severity varies greatly between cases and between admins. There's no established case-law on which woke infraction goes to which penalty, there's no equation of every slur mapped to numbers of weeks banned.
As an admin at mge.tf, I have this dilemma: do I allow for a grey zone? If I was 100% strict on infractions and permabanned anyone with a slur 10 years ago (pre-woke) in their logs, I would have half as many players. But If i'm completely permissive and let nazis and racists and annoying people, decorum would collapse and the experience of players would deteriorate and people wouldn't play the next season.
There's also the cultural battle between Chud vs Woke in America, which has trickled into the whole world. Chud likes free speech (saying slurs) and Woke likes safe spaces (cancelling enemies). Because of historical accident, or because Valve is located in woke-territory-washington, woke has been the prevailing ideology of the tf2 powers that be for ~10 years. There are lots of Woke tf2 players, so this has been mostly good, but there are also plenty of Chud tf2 players.
There’s also the problem that most people who say slurs on the internet have social problems anyway, so the solution of banning them (deeper social exile) is particularly harsh. The punishment (exile) of the symptom (maladjustment) worsen the symptom. Similar to extreme ideologies. Part of their appeal is that they are underdog revolutionaries fighting the power structures. So when I ban a nazi for being racist, I am proof that anti-nazi forces rule the world, and he becomes a more strident nazi. The punishment worsens the symptom.
Starting in 1787, Britain started sending criminals in their overcrowded prisons to a penal colony in Australia
I propose the equivalent for tf2: a Penal Colony League. A league where the code of conduct is: have thick skin, don’t use hacks. This would provide a place for the thousands of players who are banned to play the game they love without worrying about who is streaming or who will report them. It would also benefit the Woke leagues, because they could finally be completely strict about social decorum, when the punishment is league transfer not complete social exile. Instead of one league with a gray zone, we can have two leagues with a strict membrane.
I am not proposing that I will run this league, mge.tf is enough work for me. I also don’t want the reputational damage of being associated with something like that.
The penal colony wouldn’t have in-game medals, as value has its own code of conduct.
All of the code for running a tf2 league is open source on the mge.tf github, and the ozfortress league uses an open source league software as well.
Consider the woke vs chud war in America. Right now it is being fought in discord dms, in league bans, in report tickets. It could instead be fought on cp_process_f12, cp_metalworks_f7, and koth_product_final.
It’s also in tf2’s DNA: its a cultural proxy war (mercenaries) of wider power structures (Mann brothers) battling over a worthless gravelpit territory (tf2 bragging rights). RED vs BLU
tf2 has lots of players banned slurs, harassment, and generally being a nuisance.
this is a good thing for many reasons: it keeps a more professional appearance for outside eyes, it prevents vulnerable players from being harassed, it deters sportsmanship from devolving into a toxic cesspool.
However, it is also a bad thing: fewer players play in the already thin divisions, punishment severity varies greatly between cases and between admins. There's no established case-law on which woke infraction goes to which penalty, there's no equation of every slur mapped to numbers of weeks banned.
As an admin at mge.tf, I have this dilemma: do I allow for a grey zone? If I was 100% strict on infractions and permabanned anyone with a slur 10 years ago (pre-woke) in their logs, I would have half as many players. But If i'm completely permissive and let nazis and racists and annoying people, decorum would collapse and the experience of players would deteriorate and people wouldn't play the next season.
There's also the cultural battle between Chud vs Woke in America, which has trickled into the whole world. Chud likes free speech (saying slurs) and Woke likes safe spaces (cancelling enemies). Because of historical accident, or because Valve is located in woke-territory-washington, woke has been the prevailing ideology of the tf2 powers that be for ~10 years. There are lots of Woke tf2 players, so this has been mostly good, but there are also plenty of Chud tf2 players.
There’s also the problem that most people who say slurs on the internet have social problems anyway, so the solution of banning them (deeper social exile) is particularly harsh. The punishment (exile) of the symptom (maladjustment) worsen the symptom. Similar to extreme ideologies. Part of their appeal is that they are underdog revolutionaries fighting the power structures. So when I ban a nazi for being racist, I am proof that anti-nazi forces rule the world, and he becomes a more strident nazi. The punishment worsens the symptom.
Starting in 1787, Britain started sending criminals in their overcrowded prisons to a penal colony in Australia
I propose the equivalent for tf2: a Penal Colony League. A league where the code of conduct is: have thick skin, don’t use hacks. This would provide a place for the thousands of players who are banned to play the game they love without worrying about who is streaming or who will report them. It would also benefit the Woke leagues, because they could finally be completely strict about social decorum, when the punishment is league transfer not complete social exile. Instead of one league with a gray zone, we can have two leagues with a strict membrane.
I am not proposing that I will run this league, mge.tf is enough work for me. I also don’t want the reputational damage of being associated with something like that.
The penal colony wouldn’t have in-game medals, as value has its own code of conduct.
All of the code for running a tf2 league is open source on the [url=https://github.com/mgetf]mge.tf github[/url], and the [url=https://github.com/ozfortress]ozfortress[/url] league uses an open source league software as well.
Consider the woke vs chud war in America. Right now it is being fought in discord dms, in league bans, in report tickets. It could instead be fought on cp_process_f12, cp_metalworks_f7, and koth_product_final.
It’s also in tf2’s DNA: its a cultural proxy war (mercenaries) of wider power structures (Mann brothers) battling over a worthless gravelpit territory (tf2 bragging rights). RED vs BLU