ESEA Map Poll

#61

owl

0 Frags – +

they just needed to shorten the cap time on coalplant by like half and it would be improved immensely

it was like old viaduct in that you could just force the uber, let them cap halfway and pop into them on point

they just needed to shorten the cap time on coalplant by like half and it would be improved immensely

it was like old viaduct in that you could just force the uber, let them cap halfway and pop into them on point

#62

Fantasmos

-2 Frags – +

http://i.imgur.com/0l84z0j.jpg

Why not koth_sandstone?

There's been a heavy need for a king of the hill alternative, and this map has been through rigorous testing in order to fit the competitive scene, but also has it's own distinct layout and meta. It would definitely bring out new strategies and playstyles unlike many of the other KOTH options and be a breath of fresh air for this comp.

Here's the thread for it: http://teamfortress.tv/thread/16114/koth-sandstone/?page=1

And here's a big imgur album so you can have a nice look at it (It's very stylish) http://imgur.com/a/5VDsO

[img]http://i.imgur.com/0l84z0j.jpg[/img]
Why not koth_sandstone?

There's been a heavy need for a king of the hill alternative, and this map has been through rigorous testing in order to fit the competitive scene, but also has it's own distinct layout and meta. It would definitely bring out new strategies and playstyles unlike many of the other KOTH options and be a breath of fresh air for this comp.

Here's the thread for it: http://teamfortress.tv/thread/16114/koth-sandstone/?page=1

And here's a big imgur album so you can have a nice look at it (It's very stylish) http://imgur.com/a/5VDsO

#63

riotbz

-4 Frags – +

i thought edifice was supposed to be a hl map

#64

gargleburry

4 Frags – +

Fantasmoshttp://i.imgur.com/0l84z0j.jpg
Why not koth_sandstone?

There's been a heavy need for a king of the hill alternative, and this map has been through rigorous testing in order to fit the competitive scene, but also has it's own distinct layout and meta. It would definitely bring out new strategies and playstyles unlike many of the other KOTH options and be a breath of fresh air for this comp.

Here's the thread for it: http://teamfortress.tv/thread/16114/koth-sandstone/?page=1

And here's a big imgur album so you can have a nice look at it (It's very stylish) http://imgur.com/a/5VDsO

i like sandstone its different from other koth maps

[quote=Fantasmos][img]http://i.imgur.com/0l84z0j.jpg[/img]
Why not koth_sandstone?

There's been a heavy need for a king of the hill alternative, and this map has been through rigorous testing in order to fit the competitive scene, but also has it's own distinct layout and meta. It would definitely bring out new strategies and playstyles unlike many of the other KOTH options and be a breath of fresh air for this comp.

Here's the thread for it: http://teamfortress.tv/thread/16114/koth-sandstone/?page=1

And here's a big imgur album so you can have a nice look at it (It's very stylish) http://imgur.com/a/5VDsO[/quote]
i like sandstone its different from other koth maps

#65

Obi

-10 Frags – +

safrixlast is awful
spire is overrated and bad
mid is the only okay part of this map and thats because scout is a cool class

How is last awful, compared to maps like process (pushing in) and granary (pushing out). Blands is like the 'gold standard' map to be able to push out of (bar snakewater). Pretty much ever backup I've witnessed with on that map was due to poor communication and not a million hiding spots.

[quote=safrix]
last is awful
spire is overrated and bad
mid is the only okay part of this map and thats because scout is a cool class[/quote]

How is last awful, compared to maps like process (pushing in) and granary (pushing out). Blands is like the 'gold standard' map to be able to push out of (bar snakewater). Pretty much ever backup I've witnessed with on that map was due to poor communication and not a million hiding spots.

#66

rosie

-6 Frags – +

blands last is fine imo but the cap time is so dumb it ruins it

#67

Killing

-12 Frags – +

cp_granary has been voted out. Now decide which map you want voted in.

http://play.esea.net/index.php?s=poll&d=comments&id=1050

cp_granary has been voted out. Now decide which map you want voted in.

http://play.esea.net/index.php?s=poll&d=comments&id=1050

#68

6rltBVO

3 Frags – +

.

#69

sola

-5 Frags – +

give sandstone a shot? it seems very interesting, and if it fails we can always vote it out next season.

EDIT: if koth_warmfront had been added after a few tweaks, I feel like that would have a much better shot of making it in this season

give sandstone a shot? it seems very interesting, and if it fails we can always vote it out next season.

EDIT: if koth_warmfront had been added after a few tweaks, I feel like that would have a much better shot of making it in this season

#70

pokemonizepic

2 Frags – +

looks like granary is staying in

#71

rowrow

5 Frags – +

glassworks would be alright in a few more tweaks I think, but it's not ready now.

#72

DanceNumber

9 Frags – +

Remove granary, replace with maps no one outside of europe and ugc has played.

(this is why we need new map scrims/pugs)

Remove granary, replace with maps no one outside of europe and ugc has played.

(this is why we need new map scrims/pugs)

#73

cleanbuddy

1 Frags – +

i thought glassworks was more highlander-based

#74

jdm

-5 Frags – +

Every map is utter shit

Tf2 is dead

Show Content

not really

Every map is utter shit

Tf2 is dead

[spoiler]not really[/spoiler]

#75

junemofu

15 Frags – +

WHERE IS COALPLANT KILLING

#76

Phi

cp_sunshine, cp_cardinal

7 Frags – +

I'm just as surprised as you are. Why's koth_coalplant not in that vote?

#77

tatuwah

7 Frags – +

rofl welcome back granary

#78

gargleburry

-1 Frags – +

ashville in the votings maybe as well?

#79

plinko

4 Frags – +

Granary is dead, long live granary.

#80

eee

11 Frags – +

DanceNumberRemove granary, replace with maps no one outside of europe and ugc has played.

(this is why we need new map scrims/pugs)

maybe ppl would play maps if they were in ESEA

granary is so boringgggggggg

u all know granary is a shit map like take a chance on something that might kill ur fun for a week compared to something that WILL kill ur fun for a week

[quote=DanceNumber]Remove granary, replace with maps no one outside of europe and ugc has played.

(this is why we need new map scrims/pugs)[/quote]
maybe ppl would play maps if they were in ESEA

granary is so boringgggggggg

u all know granary is a shit map like take a chance on something that might kill ur fun for a week compared to something that WILL kill ur fun for a week

#81

hooky

2 Frags – +

If anyone would like this, I could start working on koth_warmfront again. I may have to start from scratch though since I don't remember if I still have the VMFs.

riot124i thought edifice was supposed to be a hl map

No, it was intended to be a Gpit replacement. But I believe the consensus ended up being that A/D is not as good for 6s as 5CP or KOTH.

If anyone would like this, I could start working on koth_warmfront again. I may have to start from scratch though since I don't remember if I still have the VMFs.

[quote=riot124]i thought edifice was supposed to be a hl map[/quote]
No, it was intended to be a Gpit replacement. But I believe the consensus ended up being that A/D is not as good for 6s as 5CP or KOTH.

#82

6rltBVO

0 Frags – +

.

#83

sola

8 Frags – +

eeeDanceNumberRemove granary, replace with maps no one outside of europe and ugc has played.

(this is why we need new map scrims/pugs)
u all know granary is a shit map like take a chance on something that might kill ur fun for a week compared to something that WILL kill ur fun for a week

!!!

marquee My only question is why does everyone seem to complain so much more vocally about sunshine yet they choose to get rid of granary again in an empty gesture because I know that I'd rather play 2 straight weeks of granary rather than deal with sunshine if I had the choice.

because sunshine gets attention from its dev and if youre vocal about a issue with it, it will probably be fixed.

[quote=eee][quote=DanceNumber]Remove granary, replace with maps no one outside of europe and ugc has played.

(this is why we need new map scrims/pugs)[/quote]

u all know granary is a shit map like take a chance on something that might kill ur fun for a week compared to something that WILL kill ur fun for a week[/quote]

!!!

[quote=marquee] My only question is why does everyone seem to complain so much more vocally about sunshine yet they choose to get rid of granary again in an empty gesture because I know that I'd rather play 2 straight weeks of granary rather than deal with sunshine if I had the choice.[/quote]

because sunshine gets attention from its dev and if youre vocal about a issue with it, it will probably be fixed.

#84

lucrative

4 Frags – +

Would really like to see another koth map in the rotation so I'm just gonna vote for that, glassworks I think is supposed to be geared towards highlander but it's actually a really nice map, I could see it being very good for 6s

#85

SpaceCadet

-3 Frags – +

cp_follower

What would be the problem with bringing back an old map that has been through league play before, like follower, to replace granary?

cp_follower

What would be the problem with bringing back an old map that has been through league play before, like follower, to replace granary?

#86

owl

7 Frags – +

SpaceCadetcp_follower

What would be the problem with bringing back an old map that has been through league play before, like follower, to replace granary?

follower is just granary with a worse version of blands mid

[quote=SpaceCadet]cp_follower

What would be the problem with bringing back an old map that has been through league play before, like follower, to replace granary?[/quote]

follower is just granary with a worse version of blands mid

#87

Xan

6 Frags – +

Is it possible to get a re-vote with coalplant in? I mean, people have been posting in this thread as if Coalplant was an eventuality in the map vote, but somehow it's not in. When and how are these things decided, I voted for Sandstone for variety and because I am sick of Granary but coalplant not getting a chance on the vote seems ridiculous.

#88

junemofu

11 Frags – +

there needs to be 3 votes

1. which is the shittiest map in the rotation right now (and an extra box where you can nominate a map to be played next season)
2. which of the nominated maps is the most promising
3. would you rather play the old map or the new map

there needs to be 3 votes

1. which is the shittiest map in the rotation right now (and an extra box where you can nominate a map to be played next season)
2. which of the nominated maps is the most promising
3. would you rather play the old map or the new map

#89

-Riley

3 Frags – +

I feel like putting keep granary on the list for new maps is kind of a bad idea becasue basically everyone that didnt vote it out will probably vote it back in creating an unbalenced vote and making it kind of inevitable that the granary legacy will continue but hey i wanted logjam and it looks like sandstone would have won regardless.

#90

Muma

8 Frags – +

Would anybody be interested in pugging logjam, glassworks and sandstone today? I wouldn't mind hosting some inhouses and seeing if we can base an opinion off of those and see if any of them play better than Granary, at least in pugs. The fact that Granary is hardly even played in pugs might be an indicator of a bad/not fun map, and if one of these is actually enjoyed and played well, maybe it'll help us decide.

Edit: can tryout Dagger's Granary_pro as well

Would anybody be interested in pugging logjam, glassworks and sandstone today? I wouldn't mind hosting some inhouses and seeing if we can base an opinion off of those and see if any of them play better than Granary, at least in pugs. The fact that Granary is hardly even played in pugs might be an indicator of a bad/not fun map, and if one of these is actually enjoyed and played well, maybe it'll help us decide.

Edit: can tryout Dagger's Granary_pro as well