I just want to double clarify that most of the fault with our IM fiasco is with queequey for being a huge baby and a rule nerd. From talking about this situation with people I've heard a surprising number of accounts of him doing similar stuff in the past so I wouldn't put too much on RGL there.
Fleskore screwed up by:
1) Not posting his approval in match comms, or contacting anyone on our team about it in any way, leading us to believe that their denial was never approved. From our perspective they attempted to deny our default ringer and nothing came of it, so even if the denial was reasonable we would have no way to know we had to find another ringer
2) Taking (RGL staff member) queequey's word at face value that darty is an egregious ringer on medic, instead of looking at his logs or asking any other players. Not every admin has to know every player but it's really easy to assess most people's rough skill level in like 5 minutes (especially when there's division-specific admins)
The first is fixed by better-written rules and better layed out procedures for admins to follow, like Scream said
The second is either favoritism, ignorance + laziness, or incompetence
Neither would be a problem if a mid-IM player who already missed playoffs hadn't tried to scum a win by denying a default med ringer
And once again, Scream did a really good job with the situation, putting in the time and knowledge (while out of town) to know how good Darty was, and made sure everyone was aware of his decision and what needed to happen