SylentAs cool as a promod would be (tf2classic or whatever already exists) (no hats, everyone gets 300 fps on max settings), there's already enough arguments for whitelists and map pools as it is, imagine making a promod with a few hundred people arguing whether or not demo stickies need to be unnerfed in the mod, med scout speed as well as a shitton of other possible changes like nerfing scout/hitscan air knockback, making soldier RJs take less hp, giving pyro a LG or fucking with airblast and all that crap people have been ironically or unironically suggesting over the years. The arguments would never end and more people would be mad than happy
What makes you think everyone gets a say? TF2promod wont be some pathetic democracy where we all sit at a round table having gentlemanly discussions whilst sipping tea and eating scones. TF2promod should be an absolute dictatorship, ran by an icefrog-type figure who makes all the major decisions. Sure people can voice their opinions about "how removing all the crossbow buffs was a step to far". But just know that such dissident talk will get you sent to the gulag (blacklisted from the promod).