Hi everyone, Gideon from BEING ESPORTS here.
I want to repeat that what actually happened here is this:
Two players have been banned with NO investigation, NO clear evidence, contradicting allegations (and I will defend this until this community finally understands) and NO ability to defend themselves in any way. In fact there was even evidence AGAINST what has been presented and the bans were still applied.
In case you are still thinking there is video evidence - THERE IS NOT. This is a hoax verified by the venue and the PoLAN admins to not be the case.
We (BEING ESPORTS) decided not to copy these bans after speaking to Luny for 90 minutes, Nicky and Roticher for more than an hour each, the organizers behind PoLAN and the people originally raising the allegations + countless hours of chat communication. Nobody else was willing or motivated to do this work which is understandable in a passion driven scene - I still want to clarify this because we have been the most attacked for this (besides the two banned individuals) while we have been the only ones willing to put in the work which annoys me incredibly much. We are the least involved in this scene and the only ones who invested the energy to do the actual job that was at hand.
I see that some you here have a very skewed idea of how a proper administration process should be handled but if you believe that what resulted in the bans is anything close to a "good way of handling things" I would suggest you give this some more thought. If this is the majority opinion of this scene, it is doomed anyway and there is nothing left to save.
What has been wrongfully said here:
1. No, Nicky and Roticher could have not just "said sorry and moved on". They were banned without being even given the chance to understand what potentially happened. A ban has been applied without even a minimum of due process so they had no chance to ever do that. Even if everything that was described happened (for which I have evidence it didn't) they still had no chance to apologize at any point in the process before the bans happened.
2. I have spoken to almost everyone involved (those I didn't speak to didn't want to speak/ chat). The people raising the allegations have ALL given different explanations of what happened. Person A said "Person B had confronted them" person B said she didn't but Person C had done it while person C was under the impression Person A had been the one to confront them. I am 99,9% confident that the assumed confrontation has never happened for specifically that reason. I also know for a fact that at least some of the raised allegations are false.
On top of that FIVE individual people (meaning different conversations not started by me on different days) at ÜBERFEST confirmed that the only person insiting on the allegations to be 100% correct was known for raising wrongful claims like this and misrepresenting things that had happened in the past (NOT LUNY) which gave me even more of a good idea of what probably happened at PoLAN.
3. I am not saying nothing of the described behaviour happened at PoLAN. What I am saying is that this does not justify a ban.
My opinion (which doesn't matter too much but I still woud like to share it) is:
People were weird (nothing sexual and nothing involving physical touch - this was confirmed by EVERYONE including Luny), they were not confronted because nobody was grown up or brave enough to confront them but they said they had because they didn't want to own them not having done it. ALL further instances of approaching Luny then were seen as in contrast to the confrontation (which never took place) and everything else was therefore interpreted based on wrong information. This makes a normal situation seem weird without Nicky or Roticher being at fault for it. This furthermore made it impossible for them to notice on site. After the event, rather than owning the mistake of never confronting them about it, a small group of people rather insisted on things having taken place that never have to make the thing sound so horrible that a ban had to take place. Even people that were originally part of the allegating group have now confirmed that this is likely what happened and did so publicly in a different part of this forum.
Also what Luny is saying about me is once again quite inaccurate in just the same way as what was described to have happened on site but I just don't want to be a part of this discussion anymore. There has been so much misrepresentation of circumstances it is just surprising that anyone still believes in it.
I am tired of defending myself and our event for being the only ones doing our job here. The only thing accurate is that I stopped responding via DMs to her (in case of ONE question) at some time but not intentionally but rather because I was speaking to five different people in DMs at that time. I was told that the important information would be sent onward to Luny by someone else involved. So her question was answered, just not directly. Everything else is partially or fully incorrect.
Let me close with this:
Parts of this community have an incredibly weird idea how these things should be handled that are far away from what I would deem a good approach. Allegation = Ban is not a logic that can ever lead to anything good in the world. At the same time they would rather be right than being honest and just and I and our organization will NEVER accept or follow this path. It is a shame that the bans have not been fully reverted by every TO involved (with an excuse on top of it) as that is the only logical way to move forward and in any other place than a niche gaming community, Nicky and Roticher should get their lawyers involved to fight (and win) this 100% of the time.
This is the only post I will add to this discussion and will be my final participation in the entire case. I will leave it open for you to decide what you want to believe.
Just ask yourselves this is you are uncertain what to believe: Why would we invest days of work and risk significant financial and reputation damage to our event to defend two community members we don't know and have never met in our life (to this day)?