MR_SLINTino_ LETTERS
Let's go point by point here: for point A, everything already does come out of pocket or is donated. As for the paid subscription thing, I feel to see how that is different than the already established donator perks, which gives donators a badge in chat. Though your system is monthly, I don't see people spending $5 a month for a chatt badge in Pugchamp, as unlike twitch, IT WOULD ONLY BE APPLICABLE IN ONE LOCATION.
B: You've already expressed some issues with this, like the queuing as a class idea. But there's also the issue that playing with friends becomes much harder, as (and I might be wrong here as I rarely use the system) queuing as a group of 6, if that's even allowed, takes longer to find matches in solo queue areas.
C. ESEA has an established pug system, and no one uses it.
D. TF2Center has a reputation for poor admins, this combined with their decision to mandate ads and other poor decision making leads me to think they aren't ideal candidates.
E. Valve doesn't do shit. We, as a community, don't have any evidence to support the fact that they give a shit about competitive tf2, except for what you and a few others have said. I'm not saying I don't trust you, I'm just saying that this shows very little commitment and support from Valve.
F. I fail to see how this would solve the main problems of pugchamp: lack of queued meds, and lack of servers.
To address other concerns about time taken for picks etc. Pugchamp currently works such that the system for server set up is entirely linear, the glitch which causes mumble info and server info to come out so late stems from the fact that the pugchamp system requires that step 1 be done before step 2, regardless of if step 1 actually leads to step 2. So if step 1 bugs out, the system cannot advance and continue getting the server set up until the glitch is resolved. As for streamlining the picking process, I don't really see what's wrong with the actual system of picking, besides the way that overrides work. A new pug system will not fix a lack of meds willing to play. Pugchamp mainly needs more servers, for both that and mixchamp. Once we have those, we can have a look at other issues.
You have to remember that competitive TF2 is not a very profitable community as of right now. For a community-run, free to use pug site to survive, it relies on the generosity of its users. Unless Pugchamp wants to be a completely aids site like TF2C and require users to not use adblock or pay, I doubt Pugchamp will find the funds for another server without more donations.