It is completely mind boggling how the RGL highlander admin team came to these decisions. I'll break this down into three main topics, the map pool, the div structure, and overall communication with the players/community.
The Map Pool
First of all, I'm all for making changes to the map pool. It keeps the game and meta fresh. However the changes should be gradual and logical. For a while now, theatreTECHIE has been working on an attack defend map named Nidal. This map is meant to replace cp_steel and is the same gamemode. theatreTECHIE has been testing this map in pugs for a while now and getting feedback from upper div highlander players. This is great! RGL decided this would be an appropriate time to put Nidal into the map rotation, no problems there from me. But for some reason they decided that instead of replacing Steel with Nidal, a map designed to replace it, it would be better to remove the long standing payload map Upward instead, with the stated reason being that both maps run the same config and Steel is more popular than Upward. For the 6's players reading, this would be as if you had Snakewater replaced with Gravelpit and the admins just said "they're both control point maps".
The community was not polled on which map we wanted to take out of the pool for Nidal, only our overall enjoyment of maps. So now the admin team has decided to change the balance of gamemodes in highlander without asking the players at all. This has serious implications on playoff map picks, as its there are more koth maps than payload for the first time in a long time.
To make matters worse, the admin team decided to make a SECOND map pool change at the same time. For the third koth map, which traditionally rotates between several different maps, they decided to put in koth_proside. This is a new community version of lakeside which has not been played before in RGL. But if that isn't bad enough, unlike Nidal, this map has not even been tested! How is it acceptable to replace a map with a new version which has had zero testing at all in NA.
For the record, Nidal being in the rotation is a good change, but upward taken out for it is what many are upset about.
The Div Structure
The admin team also decided to remove essentially remove two divisions in highlander.
The division formally called Main is now known as Advanced-2 and will be 8 team round robin.
The division formally called Intermediate is now known as Main and have entry fees.
But for some reason players in Advanced-2 will receive the same medals as Advanced-1, essentially downplaying the accomplishment of being in Advanced, as now the division formally known as Main gets the same medals.
Communication from RGL Staff
None of these changes were polled by the highlander team before making these decisions. This isn't the first time they've made sweeping changes without informing the community, and I'm sure it won't be the last. Every time it happens, one of the admins will eventually make some generic statement saying "We apologize, we will have a survey question about this next season." But at some point they should realize to add these questions to the survey BEFORE making the obviously controversial calls.
Also, in order to even partake in the RGL surveys, you must have played in the prior season. People take breaks all the time, it is crazy not to have a say in potentially major changes to the league because you took a season off at the wrong time. An IM player could easily take the summer season off due to being on vacation, and come back to their division being replaced with a paid alternative without having the chance to give any input. Perhaps change the system to allow anyone who's played in the past several seasons have a voice.
As a somewhat tangential point, when the discussion in the RGL discord (the only official place on rgl since the forums are gone) is criticizing admin communication, members of the staff decide to be rude and sarcastic.
https://i.imgur.com/Gn4qN5h.png
https://i.imgur.com/hsaZsSf.png
https://i.imgur.com/rxiV81B.png