Incoming wall of thoughts and text
When you think about it, getting into higher level competitive play outside of matchmaking takes a decent bit of grinding certain skills.
- Learning basic air strafing inside the source engine isn't exactly something that develops overnight, especially if you have people that all their time in tf2 have just played in low gravity all crit trade servers
- To top that, if a player wants to play any sort of aiming/hitscan class, they will need to learn how to adequately track, which also doesn't come very easily
- Not only that, but some of the most cherished weapons that people love and have played with all their time in tf2 and think that it's the "best weapon combination in tf2 and will make even players like b4nny quake in his boots" may not be allowed. This one is on valve for fixing though, since we can make thread after thread here about "how certain weapons should be changed" but we can't change certain weapons if we wanted to without major hinting, suggesting, rallying, and rioting. And even then it's still up in the air as to whether or not our suggestions and efforts are going to be in vain.
- Matchmaking also has a number of blatant things that need to be fixed to help newer players get into competitive. It was a huge flop at release (to say the least) but progress has been made since.
But on my (and many others') opinion on things such as the right gamemode to attract a lot of attention/viewers, it's certainly 6v6 in 5cp maps with one or 2 koth maps in the mix as well. I personally would like to see some other maps possibly modified (such as fastlane or maybe coldfront) to better suit competitive play so that we don't have to stick to just the small number of maps that longtime fans are so used to seeing. Stopwatch cp isn't going anywhere in all honesty, we saw that with gravelpit in the old times and how it eventually got booted out of the map pool since teams didn't want to play such a unique gamemode.
As for the "6s players are egotistical and think that their game must be protected" theory, anyone and everyone that still believes this is utterly retarded. I'm not usually one to say things like that, but considering how much people were talking about unlocks like the rescue ranger and the cow mangler when the global whitelist was announced only to see that it hasn't exactly made the largest impact ever on how the game plays at the highest level just blows that statement completely out of the water. Sure the cow mangler is a little bit better than the rocket launcher in full on DM fights since you don't have to worry about ammo, but if you're changing class to go engineer + gunslinger to counter one player with one special weapon in the server, then you've got to really rethink how you look at the game.
I'm getting tired at unloading my thoughts into this so I'll leave my thoughts with one final statement: I'm super happy that we're getting more communication with actual people at valve, but maybe as a suggestion for the future some of the top players could put on exhibitions to experiment with different things in the future, like one class limits and dedicated specialists (such as a top engie, spy, or pyro) show his/her craft for a map so that these things can be looked at with some of the absolute best talent in a certain role. We won't know until we try it, but the door is ajar, and ears on the other side are open to hear.
Sorry for the essay but I had a lot of thoughts jumping around in my mind about this