Who is the best?

#31

Change

9 Frags – +

where is delpo

#32

botmode

0 Frags – +

duwatna
raymon
blaze
~~banny~~ lansky
astt
clockwork

or something like that

duwatna
raymon
blaze
[s]banny[/s] lansky
astt
clockwork

or something like that

#33

highfive

16 Frags – +

hello yes where is delpo

#34

Connie

6 Frags – +

no DaveAC option for roamer :(

#35

botmode

12 Frags – +

highfivehello yes where is delpo

hello yes where is highfive

[quote=highfive]hello yes where is delpo[/quote]
hello yes where is highfive

#36

aim-

8 Frags – +

having a ballot this huge makes this subjective

if youre trying to look for the best you REALLY NEED to trim the list down to like 3 or 4 players

having a ballot this huge makes this subjective

if youre trying to look for the best you REALLY NEED to trim the list down to like 3 or 4 players

#37

Corunson

4 Frags – +

aim-having a ballot this huge makes this subjective

if youre trying to look for the best you REALLY NEED to trim the list down to like 3 or 4 players

I see what you mean, but i feel only 3 or 4 players is too few. What would be best is to have a fill in your answer poll. instead of a list have people simply write down the best players in their opinion

[quote=aim-]having a ballot this huge makes this subjective

if youre trying to look for the best you REALLY NEED to trim the list down to like 3 or 4 players[/quote]

I see what you mean, but i feel only 3 or 4 players is too few. What would be best is to have a fill in your answer poll. instead of a list have people simply write down the best players in their opinion

#38

580938

6 Frags – +

#39

warraha

1 Frags – +

WTH WHY THERES NO MUUQI IN OFFCLASSER POLL?????

#40

Tino_

9 Frags – +

Man how are people not voting plat on demo? Is there just no one around from that era anymore?

#41

nuze

3 Frags – +

2ez 4 duweezy tbh

#42

cin

3 Frags – +

=

#43

Corunson

5 Frags – +

Tino_Man how are people not voting plat on demo? Is there just no one around from that era anymore?

Biggest surprise for me is TLR is 5TH ON POCKET. I expected him to be a top 2 person

[quote=Tino_]Man how are people not voting plat on demo? Is there just no one around from that era anymore?[/quote]

Biggest surprise for me is TLR is 5TH ON POCKET. I expected him to be a top 2 person

#44

Tino_

5 Frags – +

unskilledTino_Man how are people not voting plat on demo? Is there just no one around from that era anymore?the platinum era was quite a while ago dude
i am not confident voting someone in who i did not get to watch or play against in his prime

Fair, but then why is everyone voting for b4nny? Same era but different reasoning?

[quote=unskilled][quote=Tino_]Man how are people not voting plat on demo? Is there just no one around from that era anymore?[/quote]
the platinum era was quite a while ago dude
i am not confident voting someone in who i did not get to watch or play against in his prime[/quote]

Fair, but then why is everyone voting for b4nny? Same era but different reasoning?

#45

Corunson

2 Frags – +

Tino_Fair, but then why is everyone voting for b4nny? Same era bit different reasoning?

id go with recent seasons and i55 helping him soar in the pocket category

[quote=Tino_]Fair, but then why is everyone voting for b4nny? Same era bit different reasoning?[/quote]
id go with recent seasons and i55 helping him soar in the pocket category

#46

trippa

13 Frags – +

my votes

demoman: termo (the only other choices are b4nny and numlocked tbh)
medic: shade (duh)
roamer: mike (blaze and seagull were really good but I think this one is obvious)
pocket: platinum (maybe nostalgia goggles for this one but platinum was a force on pocket that I haven't seen since)
scouts: clockwork & ruwin (starkie is better but I wanted to vote for ruwin since I liked him more)
offclasser: sheep (duh)

my votes

demoman: termo (the only other choices are b4nny and numlocked tbh)
medic: shade (duh)
roamer: mike (blaze and seagull were really good but I think this one is obvious)
pocket: platinum (maybe nostalgia goggles for this one but platinum was a force on pocket that I haven't seen since)
scouts: clockwork & ruwin (starkie is better but I wanted to vote for ruwin since I liked him more)
offclasser: sheep (duh)

#47

Tino_

11 Frags – +

Starry_NebulaeTino_Fair, but then why is everyone voting for b4nny? Same era bit different reasoning?id go with recent seasons and i55 helping him soar in the pocket category

I mean pocket and scout makes sense to some degree, but he is ranked #1 on demo and the last time he played was in the plat era, so if most people never saw plat play then they also never saw b4nny play.

[quote=Starry_Nebulae][quote=Tino_]Fair, but then why is everyone voting for b4nny? Same era bit different reasoning?[/quote]
id go with recent seasons and i55 helping him soar in the pocket category[/quote]
I mean pocket and scout makes sense to some degree, but he is ranked #1 on demo and the last time he played was in the plat era, so if most people never saw plat play then they also never saw b4nny play.

#48

cin

5 Frags – +

=

#49

Corunson

2 Frags – +

Tino_I mean pocket and scout makes sense to some degree, but he is ranked #1 on demo and the last time he played was in the plat era, so if most people never saw plat play then they also never saw b4nny play.

His title of "Pipe jesus" is still a name known throughout today, also the i46, i49 documentary, and the b4nny legacy videos have a lot of exposure. this is my best guess as to why b4nny is more known for demo

[quote=Tino_]
I mean pocket and scout makes sense to some degree, but he is ranked #1 on demo and the last time he played was in the plat era, so if most people never saw plat play then they also never saw b4nny play.[/quote]

His title of "Pipe jesus" is still a name known throughout today, also the i46, i49 documentary, and the b4nny legacy videos have a lot of exposure. this is my best guess as to why b4nny is more known for demo

#50

subhuman

-4 Frags – +

Tino_Fair, but then why is everyone voting for b4nny? Same era but different reasoning?

A strike team of b4nny subs was dispatched to this thread.

[quote=Tino_]Fair, but then why is everyone voting for b4nny? Same era but different reasoning?[/quote]
A strike team of b4nny subs was dispatched to this thread.

#51

gwendolyn

7 Frags – +

termo
raymon
seagull
lansky
clockwork
yz50

#52

tsar

6 Frags – +

cw
squid
blaze
yuki
numlocked
shade

#53

Streep36

6 Frags – +

cw
starkie
seagull
mike
numlocked
raymon

#54

denisbit13

-1 Frags – +

where dennia offclass

#55

Aefax

7 Frags – +

Also I think it's crazy that yuki is so far down for pockets. His i52 performance was one of the best performances I've seen to this day.

#56

maraudeR

4 Frags – +

only 2 votes for ipz ? ?

#57

EoN

3 Frags – +

CW (best scout to ever play the game)
Starkie (excellent playmaker)
-blaze (excellent playmaker)
Kaptain (unbelievably consistent and very adaptable)
bdonski (best post-nerf demo (although you could swap him with duwatna))
Raymon (incredible mechanics and overall a sublime player)
Off-classer: 5hp (his performance at i52 was incredible)

#58

sops

7 Frags – +

I'm surprised Shrugger is listed so low...

#59

viper

9 Frags – +

although i sympathize with people who say names are missing from these lists, there's already far too many names to choose from, any more would make a few of these decisons impossible

if this were to be done accurately, then you'd have to do a custom-entry survey (so people can list whoever they want) and then just tally up results and announce winners

also if you do do this, i would include a disclaimer to list your player that you're nominating by their actual alias (aka list platinum instead of plat, habib instead of hassassin, etc.)

although i sympathize with people who say names are missing from these lists, there's already far too many names to choose from, any more would make a few of these decisons impossible

if this were to be done accurately, then you'd have to do a custom-entry survey (so people can list whoever they want) and then just tally up results and announce winners

also if you do do this, i would include a disclaimer to list your player that you're nominating by their actual alias (aka list platinum instead of plat, habib instead of hassassin, etc.)

#60

mikemat

6 Frags – +

sopsI'm surprised Shrugger is listed so low...

Its a popularity contest and shrugger doesnt get the mixup, froyo, euro or aus fanboy votes

[quote=sops]I'm surprised Shrugger is listed so low...[/quote]
Its a popularity contest and shrugger doesnt get the mixup, froyo, euro or aus fanboy votes